(The second in a series on revival)
By Ken Horn
A revival is not just a time of spiritual enthusiasm.
Revivals bring results.
Revivals are stamped as genuine when people are saved in
large numbers and when many lives are transformed. This includes Christians who
serve God with a new fervor. Healings and deliverances often accompany a move
But there are usually outward effects that raise questions,
causing some to wonder, Is this of God?
Consider the following common characteristics found in many
Surprising and unusual leadership
Jonathan Edwards, a shy, bookish, nearsighted preacher who
read his sermons word for word from a prepared manuscript, was God’s key pastor
in the First Great Awakening (c. 1734-58). The evangelist was George
Whitefield, an outgoing member of John Wesley’s Holy Club, who preached
extemporaneously and loudly enough to be heard by as many as 30,000 people.
These two men could not have had more different public personas.
Edwards recorded the events of the Great Awakening in his
writings. This reserved New England preacher from Puritan stock became the
fulcrum for defense of the occurrences in the First Great Awakening. Though he
was uncomfortable with emotionalism, he defended God’s right to work in such a
way. He could not deny the fruit.
Times of revival are led by individuals who are not bound by
tradition or afraid of criticism. Charles G. Finney, “the father of
revivalism,” blazed a trail for D.L. Moody, Billy Sunday, Billy Graham and
other soul winners when he was the first to use certain “new measures” that
were soundly criticized by many clergy. What were his new measures? Calling for
an immediate decision for Christ; the “anxious bench,” forerunner of the church
altar; informality in speaking and prayer; allowing women to pray in public;
adding new converts quickly to church membership; and open-ended meetings that
continued as long as God was pleased to move.
But innovation is never a goal in itself. God’s anointing
can rest upon traditional methods as well.
Preaching on sin, holiness and repentance dominates revival
preaching. It was said of John Wesley’s “plain and fearless preaching” that
“the power of God came with His Word.”
Though it is not necessary to travel to a revival for a
special touch from God, this has occurred in historical outpourings …
frequently with a resulting spread of the spiritual fire. Camp meetings in the
1800s drew people from all over the frontier, with many traveling farther than
they ever had in their lives.
People came to Azusa Street from all over the world. One was
William H. Durham, who was mightily touched by God when William J. Seymour
prayed for him. When Durham returned to his mission in Chicago, a move of God
began and pastors who couldn’t reach Los Angeles began attending there. Among
those filled with the Holy Spirit were A.H. Argue, who became a leader in the
Pentecostal movement in Canada, and E.N. Bell of Fort Worth, Texas, the first
chairman of the Assemblies of God.
In 1905 T.B. Barratt came from Norway and received the Holy
Spirit in a Pentecostal mission in New York City. When he returned, his own
mission became Filadelphia Church, the largest non-Lutheran Church in Norway.
A Swedish Baptist pastor, Lewi Pethrus, came to Barratt’s
church, received the Baptism and returned to Sweden, where the move of God
followed. From Sweden, it went to South America, a stronghold of revival to
Making room for unbelievers
In the Second Great Awakening, Jacob Knapp’s meetings were
so well attended and there were so many people saved that often many Christians
stayed home so there would be room for unbelievers. They used the time for home
prayer meetings. This phenomenon has frequently been repeated.
Howell Harris, the Welsh preacher converted in 1735, found
his services often accompanied by “scenes of wild enthusiasm.”
At Cane Ridge, Ky., flashpoint of the western portion of the
Second Great Awakening, it was said the sound of thousands shouting together
could be heard for miles.
The high energy of repeated praise choruses even has
precedent. At Azusa Street it was “The Comforter Has Come” that was repeated
over and over.
There were no Pentecostal denominations (by practice) when
the Spirit was poured out near the turn of the 20th century. It was the
Holiness denominations that first experienced tongues. Even before the
Assemblies of God was formed in 1914, 100 people had spoken in tongues at a
Christian and Missionary Alliance camp meeting in Nyack, N.Y. The charismatic
movement of the 1970s saw this occur in mainline churches of every stripe.
During Edwards’ sermons, there were often “cryings out in
the meeting house.” He understood this to be the result of conviction that
brought souls to Christ.
David Brainerd was the catalyst for revival among Native
Americans in 1745-46. Often in his diary he mentioned the cries and tears of
Indian hearers as indications of conviction and considered it a sign of “less
affection” for the things of God when these were not present.
High emotions, falling, crying out, tears, even shaking, all
occurred in revivals before a modern Pentecostal ever appeared. People who
“fell under the power of God” included Congregationalists, Presbyterians,
Methodists, Baptists, Anglicans and others. In the early days of the Salvation
Army (mid-1800s), in the meetings of General William Booth, “persons were
frequently stricken down … overwhelmed with a sense of the presence and power
Criticism from within the church
Charles Chauncey was revival’s chief critic in Edwards’ day.
In the face of transformed multitudes, he championed the cause of dignified
religious exercises. Forms were more important than souls.
Finney, Wesley, Moody and Sunday were all criticized by
churchmen. It is a sad but consistent pattern that professing Christians
resistant to revival are often the loudest voices against it.
In 1910, William F.P. Burton attended a meeting at which he
first witnessed speaking in other tongues; although he was convinced it was
from God, he was disturbed by people “falling to the ground, laughing, groaning,
trembling, and seeing visions.”
An older saint gave him advice that resonates today: “We
don’t encourage such manifestations, but we are not at all surprised when they
do occasionally occur. We have learned the lesson which Michal learned so
dearly, that it does not do to belittle those who are carried away with the joy
of the Lord.” (See 2 Samuel 6:16-23.)2
(This in no way absolves believers from the necessary task
of using godly discernment. There certainly have been counterfeits and excesses
that needed to be addressed.)
The sounds of sinners repenting or even Christians rejoicing
may stir some slumbering saints from their comfort zones. That’s a good thing.
The alternative is lifeless religion.
Revival is always uncomfortable, and it always includes
challenges. It is never without its problems. But it’s better than the
alternative — far better to have imperfect revival than perfect apathy.
1 James Gilchrist Lawson, Deeper Experiences of Famous
Christians (Warner Press, 1911), p. 257.
2 Colin C. Whittaker, Seven Pentecostal Pioneers (Springfield, Mo.: Gospel Publishing House, 1983), p.156.
Ken Horn is the editor of Today’s Pentecostal Evangel and blogs at Snapshots (khorn.agblogger.org)
E-mail your comments to firstname.lastname@example.org.